Current:Home > FinanceWhat to know about abortion lawsuits being heard in US courts this week -FinanceMind
What to know about abortion lawsuits being heard in US courts this week
View
Date:2025-04-18 10:08:30
When the U.S. Supreme Court undid the nationwide right to abortion last year, it did not remove the issue from the courts.
Instead, it opened a new frontier of litigation, with states passing their own restrictions and opponents challenging them in courts across the country.
This week, three state courts are hearing arguments on abortion, including a request in Texas that could establish a new legal approach for women who are seeking immediate access to the procedure because of pregnancy complications.
Some things to know about the cases:
A TEXAS WOMAN SEEKS PERMISSION FOR AN IMMEDIATE ABORTION
Most of the lawsuits that have been filed against bans and restrictions are seeking to secure general access to abortion.
But last week, a Texas woman pregnant with a terminally ill fetus decided not to wait for those challenges to be resolved. Saying that her condition poses a risk to her health and future fertility, she asked a court for permission to obtain an abortion immediately.
Doctors told 31-year-old Kate Cox that their hands were tied — despite the Texas law’s exception for when a woman’s life is at risk — and that she would have to wait for the fetus to die or carry the pregnancy to term.
A state district judge issued an order on Thursday allowing Cox to receive an abortion. The state attorney general filed an appeal, arguing that Cox’s situation does not meet the criteria for an exception. He also warned that anyone providing the abortion could still face legal consequences. On Friday, the state’s supreme court put the lower-court ruling on hold.
A pregnant woman in Kentucky is also seeking immediate access to an abortion, but the claim she filed Friday does not cite exceptions to that state’s law; rather it argues that the ban on abortion at all stages of pregnancy violates the state constitution.
ARIZONA’S DUELING LAWS
Before Arizona was a state, it had a ban on abortion that was overridden by the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, which established a nationwide right to abortion. Just before Roe was undone last year, lawmakers passed a separate ban on abortion after 15 weeks of pregnancy.
There’s been confusion and litigation over which law applies. Currently, abortions are available during the first 15 weeks of pregnancy, based on a court ruling last year that said doctors can’t be prosecuted for providing abortions during this time frame.
The Arizona Supreme Court is scheduled to hear arguments Tuesday on whether the pre-statehood ban of 1864 — which would prohibit abortions at any stage of pregnancy — should apply.
Meanwhile, Arizona abortion rights supporters are pushing to get a ballot question before voters next year that would undo both bans. Advocates in other states are attempting to put similar questions on the ballot following the success of such a measure in Ohio last month.
A BATTLE BETWEEN LOCAL AND STATE LAWS IN NEW MEXICO
New Mexico is one of seven states that allows abortions to be obtained at all stages of pregnancy, and it’s become a major destination for people from states with bans, especially neighboring Texas.
That hasn’t stopped some conservative city and county governments in the blue state from passing local abortion bans.
The state’s Democratic attorney general is challenging those bans, saying they violate the state constitution’s provision prohibiting discrimination based on sex and pregnancy status.
Most of the local laws have been put on hold by the New Mexico Supreme Court while it considers the issue. The court will hear arguments on the challenge on Wednesday.
LEGAL WRANGLING IN WYOMING
Two hearings before courts in Wyoming this week could shape litigation on the legality of abortion.
In July, Teton County District Court Judge Melissa Owens paused enforcement of a ban on abortion at all stages of pregnancy while she weighs whether to hold a trial on a challenge to the ban.
Owens is holding a hearing Thursday to choose between a trial or making a decision more quickly based on legal arguments put before her.
Prior to that, the state Supreme Court — whose five members were all appointed by Republican governors — will hear arguments Tuesday on whether to let two lawmakers and Right to Life of Wyoming intervene in the case. They contend that Republican state Attorney General Bridget Hill should defend the ban with evidence, not just legal arguments.
Hill said in a court filing that while she doesn’t object to parties being added, the case should be decided solely on the legal arguments.
The state has just one clinic that provides abortions with both medication and surgery. The Casper clinic opened in April, after a nearly yearlong delay because of damage from an arson attack. A second, in Jackson, which provides only medication abortion, has said it is closing this week because of high rent and other costs.
CHANGING LAWS IN MICHIGAN
On Monday, Democratic Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer signed the last piece of a legislative package known as the Reproductive Health Act. The package aims to reinforce and safeguard abortion rights in Michigan after voters last year approved a ballot initiative enshrining the right in the state’s constitution.
The bill repeals a law that had banned insurance coverage for abortion without purchase of a separate rider. The law, coined “rape insurance” by opponents, was passed exactly 10 years ago by a state Legislature that was controlled by Republicans.
___
Mulvihill reported from Cherry Hill, New Jersey. Associated Press reporter Joey Cappelletti in Lansing, Michigan, contributed to this report.
veryGood! (724)
Related
- Behind on your annual reading goal? Books under 200 pages to read before 2024 ends
- Princess Charlotte Has the Best Reaction to Parents William and Kate’s Major PDA Moment
- NFL Week 1 overreactions: Can Jets figure it out? Browns, Bengals in trouble
- Judge tosses suit seeking declaration that Georgia officials don’t have to certify election results
- Why Sean "Diddy" Combs Is Being Given a Laptop in Jail Amid Witness Intimidation Fears
- Police are questioning Florida voters about signing an abortion rights ballot petition
- West Virginia governor to call on lawmakers to consider child care and tax proposals this month
- Dak Prescott beat Jerry Jones at his own game – again – and that doesn't bode well for Cowboys
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- How to measure heat correctly, according to scientists, and why it matters
Ranking
- California DMV apologizes for license plate that some say mocks Oct. 7 attack on Israel
- 1 Day Left! Extra 25% Off Nordstrom Clearance + Up to 74% Off Madewell, Free People, Good American & More
- Beyoncé snubbed with no nominations for CMA Awards for 'Cowboy Carter'
- 1 Day Left! Extra 25% Off Nordstrom Clearance + Up to 74% Off Madewell, Free People, Good American & More
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- Aaron Rodgers documentary set to stream on Netflix in December
- Wisconsin Supreme Court weighs activist’s attempt to make ineligible voter names public
- Aaron Rodgers will make his return to the field for the Jets against the 49ers
Recommendation
Travis Hunter, the 2
Delaware primary to decide governor’s contest and could pave the path for US House history
Highlights as Bill Belichick makes 'Manningcast' debut during Jets vs. 49ers MNF game
Beyoncé snubbed with no nominations for CMA Awards for 'Cowboy Carter'
Realtor group picks top 10 housing hot spots for 2025: Did your city make the list?
Firefighters battling wildfire near Garden State Parkway in southern New Jersey
Illinois man wrongly imprisoned for murder wins $50 million jury award
The US accuses Iran of sending Russia short-range ballistic missiles to use in Ukraine